August 2012: Controller’s decisions at the IPO


Despite the rainy season and the monsoons, August was yet another sizzling month at the Controller’s offices!  Out of 126 decisions listed, 54 were granted (including partly allowed), 44 refused (including abandoned and withdrawn) and no file uploaded for the remainder (12).  This post is a bit delayed because when I started to compile the list in the beginning of this month, more than half of decisions were not available! .

From this month onward, I would be presenting the data according to the controller who rendered the decision. This is purely because of the feedback received from our readers: they wanted to be able to compare the decisions (or perhaps the thought process for each decision).  My personal opinion on this is that it may only be partly helpful as their are only a few controller’s who actually render the decision in detail. Most decisions are merely agreeing to the fact that the applicant made certain changes and those changes are acceptable.

APPLICATION # APPLICANT NAME Decision/Issue CONTROLLER
1062/CHENP/2008 CONSIGLIO NAZIONALE DELLE RICERCHE Granted Anoop K Joy
3324/CHENP/2006 KAO CORPORATION Refused Anoop K Joy
5040/DELNP/2005 KISSEI PHARMACEUTICAL CO. LTD. Refused Ashok Kumar
2668/DELNP/2006 BIOMARIN PHARMACEUTICAL INC Refused Ashok Kumar
4442/KOLNP/2007 VIFOR (INTERNATIONAL) AG Granted Bhaskar Ghosh
3649/CHENP/2006 SAURER GMBH & CO KG Granted C N Shashidhara
1019/CHE/2007 E2INTERACTIVE ,INC d/b/a e2Interactive,,INC Refused C Naveen Andrew
648/CHE/2003 QUALCOMM INCORPORATED Refused C Naveen Andrew
2264/DEL/2005 PANJAB UNIVERSITY Granted Dr N. Mukherjee
3483/DEL/2005 CSIR Abandoned Dr N. Mukherjee
7704/DELNP/2007 BIOMEDGENOMICS CO.,LTD. Abandoned Dr N. Mukherjee
538/MUM/2006 STRIDES ARCOLAB LIMITED Granted Dr. Amarendra Samal
2106/MUMNP/2008 HINDUSTAN UNILEVER LIMITED Granted Dr. Amarendra Samal
2429/MUMNP/2008 PEPSICO  INC. Refused Dr. Amarendra Samal
2768/MUMNP/2008 FRESENIUS KABI DEUTSCHLAND GMBH Refused Dr. Amarendra Samal
1358/MUMNP/2008 BP CORPORATION NORTH AMERICA INC. Granted Dr. Amarendra Samal
1359/MUMNP/2008 BP CORPORATION NORTH AMERICA INC. Granted Dr. Amarendra Samal
461/MUMNP/2009 DECIPHERA PHARMACEUTICALS LLC Granted Dr. Amarendra Samal
984/MUM/2006 NANDAN BIOMATRIX LIMITED Refused Dr. Dinesh P. Patil
1919/MUMNP/2008 Knbenhavns Universitet Granted Dr. Dinesh P. Patil
2358/MUMNP/2008 AMGEN INC. Granted Dr. Dinesh P. Patil
242/MUM/2005 SPAN DIAGNOSTICS LIMITED Refused Dr. Dinesh P. Patil
2051/MUM/2006 ARJUN M. MEHTA Refused Dr. Dinesh P. Patil
1985/MUM/2007 ARJUN M. MEHTA Refused Dr. Dinesh P. Patil
5205/DELNP/2006 HANMI PHARM. CO., LTD. Granted Dr.Rajesh Dixit
7457/DELNP/2007 BRISTOL-MYERS SQUIBB COMPANY Granted Dr.Rajesh Dixit
3690/DELNP/2004 INEOS NORGE HOLDINGS AS; Granted Dr.Rajesh Dixit
2336/DEL/2005 CSIR Refused Dr.Rajesh Dixit
3006/DELNP/2006 ASTRAZENECA AB Granted Dr.Rajesh Dixit
3333/CHENP/2006 GIVAUDAN SA Granted K S Hariram
2151/DEL/2004 ICAR Refused Monika Yadav
744/DEL/2005 CSIR No file uploaded Monika Yadav
1851/MUM/2006 IPCA LABORATORIES LIMITED Granted N. Ramchander
690/MUMNP/2009 BEN, YOSSI Granted N. Ramchander
3/MUMNP/2009 BOREALIS TECHNOLOGY OY Granted N. Ramchander
1046/MUMNP/2007 ACADIA PHARMACEUTICALS INC Granted N. Ramchander
1044/MUMNP/2007 ENZON PHARMACEUTICALS, INC. No file uploaded N. Ramchander
1084/MUMNP/2008 MOMENTIVE PERFORMANCE MATERIALS, INC. Granted N. Ramchander
280/MUMNP/2009 LABORATORIOS DEL DR. ESTEVE S.A. Refused N. Ramchander
139/MUM/2004 HONDA MOTOR CO., LTD., Granted N.K.MOHANTY
132/MUM/2004 MICROSOFT CORPORATON Refused N.K.MOHANTY
4094/DELNP/2006 BAYER CROPSCIENCE AG., Granted N.R.Meena
2775/DELNP/2004 SOCIETE DES PRODUITS NESTLE S.A Granted N.R.Meena
169/DELNP/2007 EISAI R & D MANAGEMENT CO., LTD. Partly allowed N.R.Meena
1203/DELNP/2007 LG CHEM.LTD., Granted N.R.Meena
2595/DELNP/2006 PFIZER INC. Granted N.R.Meena
3189/DELNP/2006 TENNECO AUTOMOTIVE  Granted Naveen Mathur
3079/DELNP/2006 BIOMERIEUX SA Granted Naveen Mathur
1447/KOLNP/2006 MOTOROLA SOLUTIONS, INC. Granted Nirmalya Sinha
352/CHE/2006 NANJUNDA SWAMY Granted Oggu Prasad Rao
647/DELNP/2006 THE PROCTER & GAMBLE COMPANY Refused P S Rao
2044/DEL/2005 THE GILLETTE COMPANY Refused P S Rao
4891/DELNP/2006 THE GILLETTE COMPANY Refused P S Rao
1045/DELNP/2006 NATIONAL OIL WELL VARCO DENMARK I/S Refused P S Rao
4904/DELNP/2005 GALBRAITH ENGINEERING PTY. LTD. Refused P S Rao
241/DEL/2007 SUMITOMO WIRING SYSTEMS, LTD Granted P S Rao
1406/DEL/2004 DRDO Refused P S Rao
5783/DELNP/2005 MEDELA HOLDING AG., Refused P S Rao
1251/MUMNP/2006 FORREST, Leonard, Edward Granted Pankaj Borkar
733/MUM/2006 DHARMENDRA RAMPAL PASI Refused Pankaj Borkar
828/MUM/2005 CROMPTON GREAVES LTD Refused Pankaj Borkar
1351/MUMNP/2007 KUHN S A Granted Pankaj Borkar
886/MUM/2005 MAHINDRA & MAHINDRA LTD Granted Pankaj Borkar
1984/MUMNP/2007 DIETER RAMSAUER Granted Pankaj Borkar
1448/CHE/2007 SIRUVALURE MURUGESAN SIVAPRAKASAM Refused Parveen Kausar Baig
2056/CHENP/2006 KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS ELECTRONICS, N.V. Granted Parveen Kausar Baig
2040/MUMNP/2007 CARDIOCORE LAB, INC. Granted Pinkesh Jain
1208/MUMNP/2006 MOBILE 365 Refused Pinkesh Jain
2237/MUMNP/2007 QUALCOMM INCORPORATED Refused Pinkesh Jain
2151/CHENP/2005 TOTOL GAS Refused Priyadharshini R.
3634/CHENP/2006 UNIVERSITE DE LIEGE Refused Priyadharshini R.
3518/CHENP/2006 DAINIPPON SUMITOMO PHARMA CO LTD No file uploaded Priyadharshini R.
337/CHE/2008 AFTON CHEMICAL CORPORATION No file uploaded Priyadharshini R.
47/CHE/2005 ISRO Granted Priyadharshini R.
5203/CHENP/2007 LOTTE CO LTD Refused Priyadharshini R.
1138/MUMNP/2006 IDEAL CURES PVT. LTD. Allowed* Issue fee Rakesh Kumar
3477/CHENP/2007 LAIRD TECHNOLOGIES, INC. No file uploaded S Thangapandian
2823/CHENP/2006 ABB OY No file uploaded S Thangapandian
5141/DELNP/2007 EMAUS KYOTO, INC., No file uploaded S.K.Roy
6524/DELNP/2007 F. HOFFMANN-LA ROCHE AG Granted S.K.Roy
5464/DELNP/2005 EXONHIT THERAPEUTICS SA Refused S.K.Roy
4841/DELNP/2007 LTS LOHMANN THERAPIE-SYSTEME AG Granted S.K.Roy
882/KOL/2007 GM GLOBAL TECHNOLOGY OPERATIONS, INC Granted Santanu Dey
7373/DELNP/2006 THE PROCTER & GAMBLE COMPANY Granted Saroj Kumar
1077/DEL/2005 KANISHK SINHA Refused Saroj Kumar
1537/DELNP/2004 MANUEL FERNANDO MEJIAS BUTRON Refused Sh.S.N.Sav
600/DELNP/2004 THOMSON LICENSING S.A. No file uploaded Sh.S.N.Sav
2996/DELNP/2004 NAGRAVISION S.A No file uploaded Sh.S.N.Sav
7003/DELNP/2006 QUALCOMM INCORPORATED No file uploaded Sh.S.N.Sav
5320/DELNP/2006 BAYER CROPSCIENCE AG No file uploaded Shah Alam
1399/DEL/2005 EXELON GENERATION COMPANY LLC No file uploaded Shah Alam
440/DELNP/2007 EXXONMOBIL CHEMICAL PATENTS INC Granted Shah Alam
3226/KOLNP/2007 AGENCOURT PERSONAL GENOMICS, INC. Refused Soumen Ghosh
1712/KOLNP/2007 BIOMIMETIC THERAPEUTICS, INC. Granted Soumen Ghosh
944/CHENP/2006 AVENTIS PHARMA S.A. 25(1) / Granted T V Madhusudhan
1978/CHENP/2006 NORTHWESTERN UNIVERSITY Refused T V Madhusudhan
5514/CHENP/2007 MORINAGA MILK INDUSTRY CO LTD Refused T V Madhusudhan
2215/CHENP/2005 BIOCON LIMITED Withdrawn T V Madhusudhan
2215/CHENP/2005 BIOCON LIMITED Withdrawn T V Madhusudhan
2127/MUM/2006 NORMAN STONE Refused Vikash Sharma
734/MUM/2006 DHARMENDRA RAMPAL PASI Refused Vikash Sharma
1390/MUMNP/2007 FAUS GROUP INC. Refused Vikash Sharma
1173/MUM/2006 RIETER INGOLSTADT GMBH Granted Vikash Sharma
884/MUM/2007 BHASKAR VITTHAL PATWARDHAN Refused Vikash Sharma
73/MUM/2007 GODREJ & BOYCE MFG CO LTD Granted Vikash Sharma
75/MUM/2007 GODREJ & BOYCE MFG. CO. LTD Granted Vikash Sharma
471/MUMNP/2006 SYNTHES GMBH Granted Vikash Sharma
2098/MUMNP/2007 MAN TURBO AG Granted Vikash Sharma
1758/MUM/2007 TATA MOTORS LIMITED Granted Vikash Sharma
3431/DELNP/2004 A. MONFORTS TEXTILMASCHINEN GMBH &CO Granted Vinod Kumar

Rajiv Kr. Choudhry

Rajiv did his engineering from Nagpur University in 2000 in electronics design technology. He has completed his LL.B. from Delhi University, Law Center II in 2006, while working as an engineer at ST Microelectronics in NOIDA. After his LL.B., he went on to The George Washington Univeristy, Washington DC to do his LL.M. in 2007. After his LL.M., he has worked in the US at a prestigious IP law firm based out of Philadelphia. Till 2014, he was Of-Counsel to a Noida based IP law firm where he specialized in advising clients on wireless, telecommunication, and high technology. Rajiv is the founder of Tech Law Associates, a New Delhi based law firm specializing in IP law, with a focus on high - technology, and patent law. His core IP interest areas are the intersection of technology and IP, Indian IP policy, innovation, and telecommunications patents. He is also an inventor with pending applications in machine-to-machine communications domain (WO2015029061).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.