Despite the rainy season and the monsoons, August was yet another sizzling month at the Controller’s offices! Out of 126 decisions listed, 54 were granted (including partly allowed), 44 refused (including abandoned and withdrawn) and no file uploaded for the remainder (12). This post is a bit delayed because when I started to compile the list in the beginning of this month, more than half of decisions were not available! .
From this month onward, I would be presenting the data according to the controller who rendered the decision. This is purely because of the feedback received from our readers: they wanted to be able to compare the decisions (or perhaps the thought process for each decision). My personal opinion on this is that it may only be partly helpful as their are only a few controller’s who actually render the decision in detail. Most decisions are merely agreeing to the fact that the applicant made certain changes and those changes are acceptable.
| APPLICATION # | APPLICANT NAME | Decision/Issue | CONTROLLER |
| 1062/CHENP/2008 | CONSIGLIO NAZIONALE DELLE RICERCHE | Granted | Anoop K Joy |
| 3324/CHENP/2006 | KAO CORPORATION | Refused | Anoop K Joy |
| 5040/DELNP/2005 | KISSEI PHARMACEUTICAL CO. LTD. | Refused | Ashok Kumar |
| 2668/DELNP/2006 | BIOMARIN PHARMACEUTICAL INC | Refused | Ashok Kumar |
| 4442/KOLNP/2007 | VIFOR (INTERNATIONAL) AG | Granted | Bhaskar Ghosh |
| 3649/CHENP/2006 | SAURER GMBH & CO KG | Granted | C N Shashidhara |
| 1019/CHE/2007 | E2INTERACTIVE ,INC d/b/a e2Interactive,,INC | Refused | C Naveen Andrew |
| 648/CHE/2003 | QUALCOMM INCORPORATED | Refused | C Naveen Andrew |
| 2264/DEL/2005 | PANJAB UNIVERSITY | Granted | Dr N. Mukherjee |
| 3483/DEL/2005 | CSIR | Abandoned | Dr N. Mukherjee |
| 7704/DELNP/2007 | BIOMEDGENOMICS CO.,LTD. | Abandoned | Dr N. Mukherjee |
| 538/MUM/2006 | STRIDES ARCOLAB LIMITED | Granted | Dr. Amarendra Samal |
| 2106/MUMNP/2008 | HINDUSTAN UNILEVER LIMITED | Granted | Dr. Amarendra Samal |
| 2429/MUMNP/2008 | PEPSICO INC. | Refused | Dr. Amarendra Samal |
| 2768/MUMNP/2008 | FRESENIUS KABI DEUTSCHLAND GMBH | Refused | Dr. Amarendra Samal |
| 1358/MUMNP/2008 | BP CORPORATION NORTH AMERICA INC. | Granted | Dr. Amarendra Samal |
| 1359/MUMNP/2008 | BP CORPORATION NORTH AMERICA INC. | Granted | Dr. Amarendra Samal |
| 461/MUMNP/2009 | DECIPHERA PHARMACEUTICALS LLC | Granted | Dr. Amarendra Samal |
| 984/MUM/2006 | NANDAN BIOMATRIX LIMITED | Refused | Dr. Dinesh P. Patil |
| 1919/MUMNP/2008 | Knbenhavns Universitet | Granted | Dr. Dinesh P. Patil |
| 2358/MUMNP/2008 | AMGEN INC. | Granted | Dr. Dinesh P. Patil |
| 242/MUM/2005 | SPAN DIAGNOSTICS LIMITED | Refused | Dr. Dinesh P. Patil |
| 2051/MUM/2006 | ARJUN M. MEHTA | Refused | Dr. Dinesh P. Patil |
| 1985/MUM/2007 | ARJUN M. MEHTA | Refused | Dr. Dinesh P. Patil |
| 5205/DELNP/2006 | HANMI PHARM. CO., LTD. | Granted | Dr.Rajesh Dixit |
| 7457/DELNP/2007 | BRISTOL-MYERS SQUIBB COMPANY | Granted | Dr.Rajesh Dixit |
| 3690/DELNP/2004 | INEOS NORGE HOLDINGS AS; | Granted | Dr.Rajesh Dixit |
| 2336/DEL/2005 | CSIR | Refused | Dr.Rajesh Dixit |
| 3006/DELNP/2006 | ASTRAZENECA AB | Granted | Dr.Rajesh Dixit |
| 3333/CHENP/2006 | GIVAUDAN SA | Granted | K S Hariram |
| 2151/DEL/2004 | ICAR | Refused | Monika Yadav |
| 744/DEL/2005 | CSIR | No file uploaded | Monika Yadav |
| 1851/MUM/2006 | IPCA LABORATORIES LIMITED | Granted | N. Ramchander |
| 690/MUMNP/2009 | BEN, YOSSI | Granted | N. Ramchander |
| 3/MUMNP/2009 | BOREALIS TECHNOLOGY OY | Granted | N. Ramchander |
| 1046/MUMNP/2007 | ACADIA PHARMACEUTICALS INC | Granted | N. Ramchander |
| 1044/MUMNP/2007 | ENZON PHARMACEUTICALS, INC. | No file uploaded | N. Ramchander |
| 1084/MUMNP/2008 | MOMENTIVE PERFORMANCE MATERIALS, INC. | Granted | N. Ramchander |
| 280/MUMNP/2009 | LABORATORIOS DEL DR. ESTEVE S.A. | Refused | N. Ramchander |
| 139/MUM/2004 | HONDA MOTOR CO., LTD., | Granted | N.K.MOHANTY |
| 132/MUM/2004 | MICROSOFT CORPORATON | Refused | N.K.MOHANTY |
| 4094/DELNP/2006 | BAYER CROPSCIENCE AG., | Granted | N.R.Meena |
| 2775/DELNP/2004 | SOCIETE DES PRODUITS NESTLE S.A | Granted | N.R.Meena |
| 169/DELNP/2007 | EISAI R & D MANAGEMENT CO., LTD. | Partly allowed | N.R.Meena |
| 1203/DELNP/2007 | LG CHEM.LTD., | Granted | N.R.Meena |
| 2595/DELNP/2006 | PFIZER INC. | Granted | N.R.Meena |
| 3189/DELNP/2006 | TENNECO AUTOMOTIVE | Granted | Naveen Mathur |
| 3079/DELNP/2006 | BIOMERIEUX SA | Granted | Naveen Mathur |
| 1447/KOLNP/2006 | MOTOROLA SOLUTIONS, INC. | Granted | Nirmalya Sinha |
| 352/CHE/2006 | NANJUNDA SWAMY | Granted | Oggu Prasad Rao |
| 647/DELNP/2006 | THE PROCTER & GAMBLE COMPANY | Refused | P S Rao |
| 2044/DEL/2005 | THE GILLETTE COMPANY | Refused | P S Rao |
| 4891/DELNP/2006 | THE GILLETTE COMPANY | Refused | P S Rao |
| 1045/DELNP/2006 | NATIONAL OIL WELL VARCO DENMARK I/S | Refused | P S Rao |
| 4904/DELNP/2005 | GALBRAITH ENGINEERING PTY. LTD. | Refused | P S Rao |
| 241/DEL/2007 | SUMITOMO WIRING SYSTEMS, LTD | Granted | P S Rao |
| 1406/DEL/2004 | DRDO | Refused | P S Rao |
| 5783/DELNP/2005 | MEDELA HOLDING AG., | Refused | P S Rao |
| 1251/MUMNP/2006 | FORREST, Leonard, Edward | Granted | Pankaj Borkar |
| 733/MUM/2006 | DHARMENDRA RAMPAL PASI | Refused | Pankaj Borkar |
| 828/MUM/2005 | CROMPTON GREAVES LTD | Refused | Pankaj Borkar |
| 1351/MUMNP/2007 | KUHN S A | Granted | Pankaj Borkar |
| 886/MUM/2005 | MAHINDRA & MAHINDRA LTD | Granted | Pankaj Borkar |
| 1984/MUMNP/2007 | DIETER RAMSAUER | Granted | Pankaj Borkar |
| 1448/CHE/2007 | SIRUVALURE MURUGESAN SIVAPRAKASAM | Refused | Parveen Kausar Baig |
| 2056/CHENP/2006 | KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS ELECTRONICS, N.V. | Granted | Parveen Kausar Baig |
| 2040/MUMNP/2007 | CARDIOCORE LAB, INC. | Granted | Pinkesh Jain |
| 1208/MUMNP/2006 | MOBILE 365 | Refused | Pinkesh Jain |
| 2237/MUMNP/2007 | QUALCOMM INCORPORATED | Refused | Pinkesh Jain |
| 2151/CHENP/2005 | TOTOL GAS | Refused | Priyadharshini R. |
| 3634/CHENP/2006 | UNIVERSITE DE LIEGE | Refused | Priyadharshini R. |
| 3518/CHENP/2006 | DAINIPPON SUMITOMO PHARMA CO LTD | No file uploaded | Priyadharshini R. |
| 337/CHE/2008 | AFTON CHEMICAL CORPORATION | No file uploaded | Priyadharshini R. |
| 47/CHE/2005 | ISRO | Granted | Priyadharshini R. |
| 5203/CHENP/2007 | LOTTE CO LTD | Refused | Priyadharshini R. |
| 1138/MUMNP/2006 | IDEAL CURES PVT. LTD. | Allowed* Issue fee | Rakesh Kumar |
| 3477/CHENP/2007 | LAIRD TECHNOLOGIES, INC. | No file uploaded | S Thangapandian |
| 2823/CHENP/2006 | ABB OY | No file uploaded | S Thangapandian |
| 5141/DELNP/2007 | EMAUS KYOTO, INC., | No file uploaded | S.K.Roy |
| 6524/DELNP/2007 | F. HOFFMANN-LA ROCHE AG | Granted | S.K.Roy |
| 5464/DELNP/2005 | EXONHIT THERAPEUTICS SA | Refused | S.K.Roy |
| 4841/DELNP/2007 | LTS LOHMANN THERAPIE-SYSTEME AG | Granted | S.K.Roy |
| 882/KOL/2007 | GM GLOBAL TECHNOLOGY OPERATIONS, INC | Granted | Santanu Dey |
| 7373/DELNP/2006 | THE PROCTER & GAMBLE COMPANY | Granted | Saroj Kumar |
| 1077/DEL/2005 | KANISHK SINHA | Refused | Saroj Kumar |
| 1537/DELNP/2004 | MANUEL FERNANDO MEJIAS BUTRON | Refused | Sh.S.N.Sav |
| 600/DELNP/2004 | THOMSON LICENSING S.A. | No file uploaded | Sh.S.N.Sav |
| 2996/DELNP/2004 | NAGRAVISION S.A | No file uploaded | Sh.S.N.Sav |
| 7003/DELNP/2006 | QUALCOMM INCORPORATED | No file uploaded | Sh.S.N.Sav |
| 5320/DELNP/2006 | BAYER CROPSCIENCE AG | No file uploaded | Shah Alam |
| 1399/DEL/2005 | EXELON GENERATION COMPANY LLC | No file uploaded | Shah Alam |
| 440/DELNP/2007 | EXXONMOBIL CHEMICAL PATENTS INC | Granted | Shah Alam |
| 3226/KOLNP/2007 | AGENCOURT PERSONAL GENOMICS, INC. | Refused | Soumen Ghosh |
| 1712/KOLNP/2007 | BIOMIMETIC THERAPEUTICS, INC. | Granted | Soumen Ghosh |
| 944/CHENP/2006 | AVENTIS PHARMA S.A. | 25(1) / Granted | T V Madhusudhan |
| 1978/CHENP/2006 | NORTHWESTERN UNIVERSITY | Refused | T V Madhusudhan |
| 5514/CHENP/2007 | MORINAGA MILK INDUSTRY CO LTD | Refused | T V Madhusudhan |
| 2215/CHENP/2005 | BIOCON LIMITED | Withdrawn | T V Madhusudhan |
| 2215/CHENP/2005 | BIOCON LIMITED | Withdrawn | T V Madhusudhan |
| 2127/MUM/2006 | NORMAN STONE | Refused | Vikash Sharma |
| 734/MUM/2006 | DHARMENDRA RAMPAL PASI | Refused | Vikash Sharma |
| 1390/MUMNP/2007 | FAUS GROUP INC. | Refused | Vikash Sharma |
| 1173/MUM/2006 | RIETER INGOLSTADT GMBH | Granted | Vikash Sharma |
| 884/MUM/2007 | BHASKAR VITTHAL PATWARDHAN | Refused | Vikash Sharma |
| 73/MUM/2007 | GODREJ & BOYCE MFG CO LTD | Granted | Vikash Sharma |
| 75/MUM/2007 | GODREJ & BOYCE MFG. CO. LTD | Granted | Vikash Sharma |
| 471/MUMNP/2006 | SYNTHES GMBH | Granted | Vikash Sharma |
| 2098/MUMNP/2007 | MAN TURBO AG | Granted | Vikash Sharma |
| 1758/MUM/2007 | TATA MOTORS LIMITED | Granted | Vikash Sharma |
| 3431/DELNP/2004 | A. MONFORTS TEXTILMASCHINEN GMBH &CO | Granted | Vinod Kumar |
