
Delhi High Court is witnessing something fresh and long overdue. The forum has long been treated as a warm host for any IP dispute, even with the weakest link to Delhi. Now things are changing. The DHC is finally giving importance to the often overlooked question of jurisdiction. Post Justice Kaurav’s watershed ruling in ABD Maestro, where he returned 17 plaints back to the plaintiff for lack of territorial jurisdiction, he is rolling the rules enlisted there across new IP suits dealing with the jurisdiction question. Today, covering 10 IP commercial suits led by Sotkon SP SLU vs Western Imaginary Transcon, he declined to entertain the plaints on lack of territorial jurisdiction by applying the forum conveniens doctrine. Notably, he had framed it as the forum non conveniens doctrine in ABD Maestro to explain why Delhi shouldn’t retain jurisdiction; here he has referred to it as forum conveniens, which I think does the job to spotlight the natural home of each of those disputes.
What’s the update?
ABD Maestro addressed mainly trademark, copyright and passing off. By this decision, he has extended the forum conveniens to patent, design, and trade secrets.
Interestingly, Justice Kaurav flags whether Banyan Tree (here, the DHC held that a mere interactive website or online presence alone isn’t enough to avail jurisdiction and pushed for a strict threshold of purposeful availment) should apply to the Patents Act. He discusses that in a case where the plaintiff specifically pleads that the impugned products violating the plaintiff’s patent are being manufactured by the defendant, then the inquiry doesn’t end on finding that samples of the defendant’s products eventually came to be delivered within the local limits of the DHC. Manufacturing is a part of lis, then place of manufacturing holds importance in deciding jurisdiction. Inquiry should go on to find where the dominant, essential part of the infringement must lie.
Bringing In Fundamental Rights
By the end of the decision, he also discusses the forum conveniens doctrine being used as an integral tool in directing a lis where it actually belongs. The doctrine is applicable even when the lis circles around fundamental rights. Even then, despite having jurisdiction to grant the relief prayed for, the Court can invoke the forum conveniens doctrine and refuse to entertain the petition. In my previous post deconstructing the ABD Maestro decision, I wrote that this doctrine isn’t new; it is just not used often. Here Justice Kaurav added that, “High Courts of Calcutta, Bombay and Madras, routinely invoke this doctrine while adjudicating a civil suit and testing it on the anvil of Clause 12 of their respective Letters Patent.”
Calling Out the Free for All
What really stood out in this ruling was openly calling out jurisdictional principles premised on a laissez-faire arrangement. Usually we talk about territorial jurisdiction in technical and almost dry terms. Seeing a decision basically saying, “No, the plaintiff getting a jurisdiction menu to hand-pick one of the many options and game the system is not a sound procedure” feels refreshing.
