Wockhardt v Remed Healthcare: Trademarks and Medicines

There have been many recent trademark cases (e.g. Merck Kgaa & Anr vs Abhinav and Ashok Trading, 2014- where Carbophar was held to be deceptively similar to the trademark Carbophage and a permanent injunction was granted.) surrounding infringement suits over trademarks related to medicines. Trademark law assesses similarity of marks from the lens of an ‘average man of ordinary intelligence’ who has ‘imperfect recollection’. Though a critical comparison of two trademarks may disclose points of differences, their overall similarity may […]

Wockhardt v Remed Healthcare: Trademarks and Medicines Read More »

Taking down websites hosting infringing content

Last week, popular torrent tracking website torrentz[dot]eu was in news after the UK Police Intellectual Property Crime Unit (PIPCU) got the domain name suspended.  Surely, to the disappointment of the right holders, the site was back online the next day.  The site’s Polish registrar restored the domain name’s server (“DNS”) entries after Torrentz’ legal team pointed out that the suspension was unlawful.  This post analyzes the legal issues behind such actions and provides a contextual background for the same.  In conclusion,

Taking down websites hosting infringing content Read More »

Heritage Trademark: The Race Over Rice

Only talk doesn’t cook the rice! Rice, a source of a number of culinary delights, especially in India, is now the fodder for a legal battle. A trademark dispute over the use of the mark ‘Heritage’ with respect to rice is unfurling before the Delhi High Court. The plaint was first rejected by a single judge but was recently restored. In 2011, LT Foods ltd filed a suit seeking permanent injunction to restrain Heritage Foods from infringing its trademark- Heritage.

Heritage Trademark: The Race Over Rice Read More »

Guest Post: Google, ARA and Open Source Licensing

Kartik Chawla brings us an extremely interesting post on the new ‘free and open hardware platform’ for modular smart phones that Google is developing. In this post he focuses on MDK’s IP licensing policies and their implications, and discusses Google’s deviation from its initial Open source approach. Kartik is a 3rd year student at Nalsar. You can view his previous guest posts for us here. Google, ARA and Open Source Licensing When Google sold Motorola, which it had bought only a

Guest Post: Google, ARA and Open Source Licensing Read More »

Madras HC: Prosthetics patent and design infringement case

The following post discusses a patent and design infringement case (M.C. Jayasingh Vs. Mishra Dhatu Nigam Limited (MIDHANI) rep. by its Managing Director, Apollo Hospitals) decided by the Madras High Court in January 2014. The court upheld the validity of the patent and design but also found no infringement by the defendants. [*long post] Facts The plaintiff along with Professor Mayilvahanan Natarajan (co-patentee) invented various prosthetics for limb salvage surgery. Made of titanium alloy or medical grade stainless steel, ‘Custom

Madras HC: Prosthetics patent and design infringement case Read More »

Tekla Corporation v. Survo Ghosh: An Attempt at Introducing the “Misuse of Copyright” Doctrine in Indian Jurisprudence

On 16th May, 2014, in the case Tekla Corporation v. Survo Ghosh,  Justice Endlaw of the Delhi High Court held that ‘copyright misuse’ does not constitute a legitimate defense for copyright infringement in India. In this post, I analyse the decision in Tekla Corporation in light of how the doctrine of copyright misuse is evolving in the USA. The judgment does not delve into the facts in detail. What can be gleaned is that the plaintiffs Tekla Corporation, Finland and Tekla India

Tekla Corporation v. Survo Ghosh: An Attempt at Introducing the “Misuse of Copyright” Doctrine in Indian Jurisprudence Read More »

SpicyIP Weekly Reviews (12th to 18th May & 19th to 25th May)

SpicyIP Highlight of the Week! We, at SpicyIP, were quite happy to see IPKat’s appreciation for our work on the blog here. (Though, we would like to mention again that as much as we’d like to have actually ‘sponsored’ them, we were only involved in a cross media partnership with INTA).   IPKat, as always, continues to provide inspiration with their phenomenal blogging. Incidentally, INTA’s 136th Annual Meeting which was held this year in Hong Kong from May 10th to May

SpicyIP Weekly Reviews (12th to 18th May & 19th to 25th May) Read More »

Karim’s Mughlai Cuisine- A spicy trademark dispute

The case of MD IFTEKHAR v. M/s KARIM HOTELS Pvt Ltd. was an appeal to the Delhi High Court decided early this month.This case essentially deals with the issue of the ownership of  trademarks The privileged position that the Court accords to registration of trademarks is made apparent in this case, even when there are suggestions that the registration is invalid. It is also a testament to the legal principle that a lower bench’s decision will not be interfered with

Karim’s Mughlai Cuisine- A spicy trademark dispute Read More »

A Note on M/S. Jagdamba Impex v. M/S. Tristar Products Pvt. Ltd

Background The Delhi HC, in M/S. Jagdamba Impex (“Appellant” who is the original defendant) v. M/S. Tristar Products Pvt. Ltd (“Respondent” who is the original plaintiff) (FAO No. 128/2014 & CM Nos. 7778-79/2014 & FAO No. 129/2014 & CM Nos. 7782-83/2014), examined the applicability of Section 15(2) of Copyright Act, 1957. The first appeal was filed under Order 43 Rule 1(r) CPC impugning the order of the trial court dated 19.2.2014 which had earlier allowed the application of the Respondent

A Note on M/S. Jagdamba Impex v. M/S. Tristar Products Pvt. Ltd Read More »

Webinar On Patenting strategies for Start-ups in the IT and ITES domains

We’re happy to announce a free webinar by IPMetrix on Patenting Strategies for Start-ups in the IT and ITES domains. Please see the details as below. LIVE WEBINAR ON PATENTING STRATEGIES FOR START-UPS in the IT AND ITES DOMAINS Date/Time: Tuesday, May 27, 2014; 11.30 AM to 12.30 PM IST (Approx. 1 hr) Event Details: Did you know that it is easier to obtain patent rights for your invention in the US compared to India? And, did you know that an

Webinar On Patenting strategies for Start-ups in the IT and ITES domains Read More »

Scroll to Top