In the month of December 2012 the Controller’s offices issued 84 decisions. Out of these 84, 46 decisions were granted (including deferred, time allowed), 34 refused (including revoked, abandoned and withdrawn) and no file uploaded for the remainder (4).
Some interesting decisions: There are three decisions related to divisional practice: 1251/KOL/2005; 1257/DEL/2007, and 3466/DEL/2005: All three are from different controllers, and yield a similar result. 1576/DEL/2006 is on application of sections 3(e), and 3(p). 106/DELNP/2008 is on application of section 3(d). 402/CHENP/2004 deals with revocation of Schering’s patent.
Some interesting decisions: There are three decisions related to divisional practice: 1251/KOL/2005; 1257/DEL/2007, and 3466/DEL/2005: All three are from different controllers, and yield a similar result. 1576/DEL/2006 is on application of sections 3(e), and 3(p). 106/DELNP/2008 is on application of section 3(d). 402/CHENP/2004 deals with revocation of Schering’s patent.
| APPLICATION NUMBER | APPLICANT | Decision / Issue | CONTROLLER |
| 1403/CHENP/2008 | BASF SE | Refused | Anoop K Joy |
| 3489/CHENP/2006 | SUMITOMO RUBBER INDUSTRIES LTD | Granted | Anoop K Joy |
| 3376/CHENP/2006 | KURARAY SPECIALITIES EUROPE GMBH | Refused | Anoop K Joy |
| 2918/CHENP/2006 | OSAKA INDUSTRIAL PROMO ORG. | Granted | Anoop K Joy |
| 1251/KOL/2006 | OTSUKA PHARMACEUTICAL CO.,LTD. | Refused | Bhaskar Ghosh |
| 3919/CHENP/2006 | MASCHINENFABRIK RIETER AG | Granted | C N Shashidhara |
| 101/CHENP/2008 | TERRACON TECHNOLOGIES LLC | Granted | C N Shashidhara |
| 3386/DELNP/2004 | THE SCRIPPS RESEARCH INSTITUTE | Abandoned | Dr N. Mukherjee |
| 1576/DEL/2006 | CENTRAL … UNANI MEDICINE | Refused* | Dr N. Mukherjee |
| 1141/MUMNP/2009 | F.HOFFMANN-LA ROCHE AG | Abandoned | Dr. Dinesh P. Patil |
| 1383/MUMNP/2007 | GILEAD SCIENCES INC. | Abandoned | Dr. Dinesh P. Patil |
| 1907/MUMNP/2007 | THE UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS | Abandoned | Dr. Dinesh P. Patil |
| 559/MUMNP/2007 | DISCUS DENTAL IMPRESSIONS INC. | Abandoned | Dr. Dinesh P. Patil |
| 220/MUMNP/2009 | SEWON CELLONTECH CO. LTD. | Abandoned | Dr. Dinesh P. Patil |
| 48/MUMNP/2010 | HADASIT MEDICAL RESEARCH | Abandoned | Dr. Dinesh P. Patil |
| 2006/MUMNP/2008 | MOLOGIC LTD | Granted | Dr. Dinesh P. Patil |
| 2775/MUMNP/2008 | THE CONCENTRATE MFG. CO. IRELAND | Abandoned | Dr. Dinesh P. Patil |
| 1198/MUM/2007 | INSTITUTE OF IMMUNOHAEMATOLOGY | Granted | Dr. Dinesh P. Patil |
| 337/DELNP/2003 | LANXESS DEUTSCHLAND GMBH | Granted | Dr.Rajesh Dixit |
| 4069/DELNP/2006 | RANBAXY LABORATORIES LIMITED | Withdrawn | Hardev Karar |
| 106/DELNP/2008 | ALFA WASSERMANN S. P. A. | Granted* | Hardev Karar |
| 88/CHE/2006 | K. GURUMOORTHY | Granted | K S Hariram |
| 564/DELNP/2007 | GE HEALTHCARE UK LIMITED | Abandoned | Monika Yadav |
| 242/DEL/2008 | MILLIPORE CORPORATION | Abandoned | Monika Yadav |
| 1458/DELNP/2006 | Tenneco Automotive Operating Company Inc. | Granted | Mr. Naveen Mathur |
| 2083/MUM/2007 | OMNIACTIVE HEALTH TECH | Granted | N. Ramchander |
| 285/MUM/2009 | NATWARLAL J. MEHTA | Granted | N. Ramchander |
| 372/MUMNP/2008 | UNIVERSITY OF MONTPELLIER I | Granted | N. Ramchander |
| 1294/MUMNP/2006 | ANGSTROM POWER INCORPORATED | Granted | N.K.MOHANTY |
| 2027/MUM/2006 | MEDIA TEK INC. | Granted* | N.K.MOHANTY |
| 655/MUMNP/2006 | QUALCOMM INCORPORATED | Refused* | N.K.MOHANTY |
| 215/MUMNP/2008 | QUALCOMM INCORPORATED | Granted | N.K.MOHANTY |
| 807/MUMNP/2006 | ESSIG, JOHN, RAYMOND | Abandoned | N.K.MOHANTY |
| 1535/MUMNP/2007 | QUALCOMM INCORPORATED | Granted | N.K.MOHANTY |
| 126/MUM/2008 | OERLIKON TEXTILE GMBH & CO. KG | Granted | N.K.MOHANTY |
| 821/MUM/2004 | MULTIMEDIA GLORY SDN. BHD. | Granted | N.K.MOHANTY |
| 19/MUMNP/2008 | QUALCOMM INCORPORATED | Granted | N.K.MOHANTY |
| 260/MUMNP/2008 | QUALCOMM INCORPORATED | Granted | N.K.MOHANTY |
| 63/MUMNP/2008 | HUMAX CO., LTD. | Granted | N.K.MOHANTY |
| 1257/DEL/2007 | GILEAD SCIENCES, INC. | Refused* | N.R.Meena |
| 840/DELNP/2007 | LG CHEM.LTD., | Granted | N.R.Meena |
| 2393/DELNP/2006 | MAGNESIUM ELEKTRON LIMITED | Granted | N.R.Meena |
| 2083/KOLNP/2006 | MOTOROLA, INC. | Granted | Nirmalya Sinha |
| 494/DELNP/2006 | SULZER PUMPEN AG, | Granted | P S Rao |
| 137/DELNP/2006 | MICHELIN RECHERCHE S.A. | Granted | P S Rao |
| 547/CHE/2006 | AUROBINDO PHARMA LIMITED | Refused | P. Rajanbabu |
| 1039/CHENP/2008 | F. HOFFAMANN-LA ROCHE AG | Granted | P. Rajanbabu |
| 1424/CHENP/2008 | EISAI R&D MANAGEMENT CO, LTD | Granted | P. Rajanbabu |
| 2092/CHE/2007 | D. K. KRISHNA MURTHY | Granted | P. Rajanbabu |
| 821/MUM/2005 | RIETER INGOLSTADT AG | Abandoned | Pankaj Borkar |
| 1617/MUM/2005 | STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA LIMITED | Abandoned | Pankaj Borkar |
| 2082/MUM/2007 | MANROLAND AG | Abandoned | Pankaj Borkar |
| 68/MUM/2004 | HONDA MOTOR CO. LTD. | Granted | Pankaj Borkar |
| 1987/MUMNP/2007 | ZF FRIEDRICHSHAFEN AG | Granted | Pankaj Borkar |
| 1525/KOLNP/2006 | FUJIKURA LTD. | Granted | Parijat Sourav |
| 2820/CHENP/2006 | ABB OY | Abandoned | S Thangapandian |
| 877/KOL/2005 | ALSTOM TECHNOLOGY LTD | Refused | Santanu Dey |
| 1077/DEL/2005 | KANISHK SINHA | Refused* | Saroj Kumar |
| 1077/DEL/2005 | KANISHK SINHA | Granted* | Saroj Kumar |
| 1686/DEL/2005 | WORTHINGTON ARMSTRONG VENTURE | Granted | Saroj Kumar |
| 3612/DELNP/2007 | LG CHEM, LTD., | No file uploaded | Sh.S.N.Sav |
| 3466/DEL/2005 | RESEARCH IN MOTION LIMITED | Refused* | Sh.S.N.Sav |
| 902/DEL/2007 | RESEARCH IN MOTION LIMITED | No file uploaded | Sh.S.N.Sav |
| 2403/DELNP/2006 | IBM | No file uploaded | Sh.S.N.Sav |
| 1395/DELNP/2007 | NIPPON STEEL CORPORATION | No file uploaded | Sh.S.N.Sav |
| 829/DELNP/2007 | THE PROCTER & GAMBLE COMPANY | Refused | Shah Alam |
| 1106/KOLNP/2006 | CENTOCOR, INC. | Granted | Soumen Ghosh |
| 5179/KOLNP/2008 | GLAXOSMITHKLINE BIOLOGICALS S.A. | Abandoned | Soumen Ghosh |
| 3889/KOLNP/2007 | DR. WILLMAR SCHWABE GMBH | Abandoned | Soumen Ghosh |
| 402/CHENP/2004 | SCHERING CORPORATION | Revoked | T V Madhusudhan |
| 3969/CHENP/2007 | TAIYO KAGAKU CO., LTD | Granted* | T V Madhusudhan |
| 3497/CHENP/2006 | VAAKYA TECHNOLOGIES | Granted | V Saravanan |
| 2894/CHENP/2007 | SILVERBROOK RESEARCH PTY LTD | Abandoned | V Saravanan |
| 623/MUMNP/2006 | OBSCHESTO S OGRANICHENNOI | Granted | Vikash Sharma |
| 560/MUMNP/2006 | Approtec USA | Refused | Vikash Sharma |
| 560/MUMNP/2006 | Approtec USA | Refused | Vikash Sharma |
| 77/MUM/2004 | HONDA MOTOR CO., LTD., | Granted | Vikash Sharma |
| 92/MUM/2006 | MAN ROLAND AG | Refused | Vikash Sharma |
| 24/MUMNP/2008 | SIEGENIA – AUBI KG | Granted | Vikash Sharma |
| 1741/MUMNP/2007 | GLATT GMBH | Granted | Vikash Sharma |
| 2318/MUM/2007 | TATA MOTORS LIMITED | Granted | Vikash Sharma |
| 2309/MUM/2007 | TATA MOTORS LIMITED | Granted | Vikash Sharma |
| 1114/DEL/2005 | ADESS SINGH | Granted | Vinod Kumar |
| 2552/DELNP/2004 | FENWAL INC., | Granted | Vinod Kumar |
