In Part I, Dr. Aakanksha Kumar argued that the Madras High Court’s order in Saravanan Hari v. Blink Commerce reached the right result without sorting out the claims it was enforcing, and that the plaintiff’s celebrity status is beside the point. Part II looks at the persona itself, a superfan figure made from CSK’s and Dhoni’s signs, and at the Blinkit advertisement that borrowed it. Aakanksha is an independent researcher and academic. Since 2019, she has designed and taught a self-created elective course across law schools titled Comparative Celebrity Laws: Personality, Publicity and Free Speech.
[Part II] Whistle, Podu? – A Simple Case, a Hard Question and a Wild Claim
Dr. Aakanksha Kumar
In Part I, I argued that the Madras High Court’s order in Saravanan Hari v. Blink Commerce reached the right result without sorting the claims it was enforcing, and that the plaintiff’s celebrity status is beside the point. Part II looks at the persona itself, a superfan figure made from CSK’s and Dhoni’s signs, and at the Blinkit advertisement that borrowed it.
Whose Persona is it Anyway? Cosplaying Superfan Figure versus Individual Persona
Here is what makes this case wild. The “personality” protected is not, in its ordinary sense, Hari’s individual, personal, non-made up face. It is a figure he built, over years. He dated the yellow paint he uses to India’s 2011 World Cup win, telling the ICC in 2019: “When Dhoni won the 2011 World Cup for us, I wanted to do something to show our gratitude.” The paint took “two to three hours” to put on. That labour is why the figure is, in a real sense, his, even though it “takes” attributes from the franchise and its players.


For Saussure (paywalled), the link between signifier and signified is conventional, not natural. The specific yellow signifies CSK only by a convention built by a franchise’s branding, broadcasts and 17 seasons of the IPL. “Dhoni” and “7” signify a cricketer whose name and number are themselves a valuable personality indicia. In Barthes’s terms, the painted superfan, as a complete sign, has become the signifier of a second-order meaning, the myth: devotion itself, the loyal Chennai crowd, the romance of fandom. That is what, in this case, Blinkit wants to borrow.
Cultural studies has long held and furthered this idea. Rosemary Coombe (paywalled) showed that celebrity images are authored in many places at once, and that audiences actively rework them – which John Fiske (paywalled) called the audience’s freedom to make its own meanings in a “semiotic democracy”. Tan and Wilson, drawing on Stuart Hall, explain this further as reappropriating an existing meaning or “trans-coding”, and further draw on Hal Foster, to describe a fandom subcultural practice that “re-codes signs”. Marc Greenberg (paywalled) notes that most publishers and artists regard fan art as “a harmless homage and expression of appreciation” and that some cosplayers have become “celebrities in their own right”. (paywalled). However, a superfan is not cosplaying a character; he is performing his own fandom in borrowed signs. That is precisely what makes his claim unusual, in-spite of the participatory use I have argued fans must remain free to make. The irony is that the order now treats the fan’s homage as his property, without considering that at least some part of its value came from CSK and Dhoni.
The advertisement: a composite of caricatures, on match day
The advertisement makes this a harder case than the order lets on. It ran on the front page of the Chennai Sunday Times on 23 March 2025, the day CSK opened their IPL season against Mumbai Indians at Chepauk, and won by four wickets. The impugned ad is reproduced below:

Its headline, “The men in yellow always deliver”, is a pun: the men in yellow are CSK, and also Blinkit’s riders in their yellow uniforms and bags. Below it, cartoon caricatures of Chennai on match day surround a curly-haired figure painted yellow on the bottom right, “THALA 7” on his chest, arms out, thumbs up. He sits directly above a “cut here” line and a ₹500 match-ticket voucher being up for grabs.
This is reminiscent of facts in two US cases – ETW found “significant transformative elements” in Rick Rush’s painting of Tiger Woods’s Masters win, “a collage of images in addition to Woods’s image”, and in Blanch v. Koons, Koons used a fragment of a photograph as raw material because “[t]he ubiquity of the photograph is central to my message”. Here, arguably, the yellow superfan is just as ubiquitous at Chepauk. The order describes Hari as wearing “Dhoni” and No. 7 (para 2); the cartoon says “THALA 7”. D.M. Entertainment cautions that “caricature, lampooning, parodies and the like…may not constitute infringement” (para 14). Kriti Sanon adds that “the mere use of a person’s identity is not, by itself, unlawful” (para 22). However, here, the inclusion of the coupon creates the problem for the defendant. While Rush’s prints “(did) not propose a commercial transaction”; this full page ad, does. In White v. Samsung, a Samsung advertisement showed a robot “dressed in a wig, gown, and jewelry”, posed beside a Wheel of Fortune game board, under the caption “Longest-running game show. 2012 A.D.” The Ninth Circuit rejected Samsung’s parody defence, observing that “the difference between a ‘parody’ and a ‘knock-off’ is the difference between fun and profit.” Warhol has since held that new expression “is not, without more, dispositive”, and that a commercial use sharing the original’s purpose “is likely to weigh against fair use”. Warhol had made his Prince series from Lynn Goldsmith’s photograph of Prince; when his Foundation licensed Orange Prince to Condé Nast for a magazine in 2016, the Court found that “[b]oth are portraits of Prince used in magazines to illustrate stories about Prince.” It is a copyright case about a single licence, though its reasoning on commercial purpose may be extended and adapted for a right of publicity case too.
Then there is the layout. Of a dozen vignettes, the one figure whose public identity is going to matches sits directly above the “cut here” line and the match-ticket voucher. The headline’s pun already puts the fan alongside CSK and the delivery riders as one more man in yellow. The timing adds to it. Writing about the brands that congratulated Manu Bhaker after Paris, Tejas Misra located the problem where “brands put their own names or taglines or otherwise market themselves in the posts”, and Blinkit’s match-day front page newspaper ad carries its logo, its tagline and a voucher. I can see the argument for the caricature, but on the papers as they stand, I think the coupon and the placement defeat it. Blinkit’s ad goes further than any congratulatory post: its logo appears at least three times, its tagline is there, its headline is its own pun, and it makes an offer. Riding a city’s match-day mood is fair game. Riding it on an identifiable persona, placed beside a ticket offer, is harder to defend.Calling the figure “fictional” does not take it far (Blinkit’s defense, para 8). The robot in White was fictional too; what mattered was whom it evoked.
Keeping the Reach Small
Dogan and Lemley draw the line I keep returning to: advertising versus merchandise. In merchandise, the plaintiff’s image is part of the product itself, and buyers want it because they admire the person, not because they think she endorsed it. In advertising, the identity is used to sell something else. This case sits squarely on the advertising side. Their preferred lens, trade mark law’s concern with confusion, also fits these facts unusually well, given the acquaintances who asked about an endorsement. Tushnet, further argues that images have distorted the right of publicity. Courts tolerate rules for drawings, video and games that would be plainly unacceptable if applied to words, and without that distortion the right would be understood as sharply limited. If I were to apply her test here, a columnist who wrote that the yellow-painted superfan with Dhoni’s No. 7 was in the stands as usual would face no suit. What makes Blinkit’s use actionable is that it was an advertisement proposing a sale, not that it was a picture. The injunction should be confined accordingly: to commercial advertising, not to all depictions of the superfan as such. Rothman’s worry is equally relevant here that the right of publicity is losing its way when it turns people into intellectual property, and that it should return to its roots in protecting individuals, famous or not, against wrongful uses of their identity. The strongest version of Hari’s claim is personal: he was made to appear to endorse a product he did not. Recast as a property-type right in the superfan persona, the claim becomes something else: a licensable asset assembled from CSK’s and Dhoni’s indicia, which he could then sell to sponsors. That is a place the law should not go by accident, in an interim order [Refer Gangjee and Dhonchak]. The fan who builds a persona, out of a team’s colours and a captain’s fan-conferred epithet (‘Thala’) is doing exactly what culture invites and permits fans to do. That is why the law should protect him against such persona being used to sell groceries without his consent, and also why it must not hand him, or anyone, a monopoly over the look of devotion itself.
For now, Hari has what he came for, at least at this stage. Blinkit is restrained from using his persona, its artwork and design materials must be preserved, and the question of accounts and damages waits for trial. Most of all, a court has said, in so many words, that a fan who was never a film star or a cricketer still holds “individual personality rights that have been acquired, whatever little it may be” (para 9). For a man who has spent over a decade wearing another man’s number, it was fitting that the win arrived on a day that adds up to it: the 16th. One plus six is seven. Thala for a reason.
