Global Innovation Index: General Deconstruction and Critique

In October 2017, I posted a brief report on the Global Innovation Index (GII) 2017 (10th edition). Over the course of the ensuing write-up, I have attempted to provide a more general review of the GII, albeit basing most viewpoints on recent reports (including the 2017 report). The objective is to acquire a better understanding of (a) the process behind such indices, (b) the inherent subjectivity and also, (c) take note of a few limitations of the GII. The GII […]

Global Innovation Index: General Deconstruction and Critique Read More »

SpicyIP Weekly Review (March 4 – 10)

By way of a special report that I highly recommend to our readers, Prashant & Balaji brought us this week’s topical highlight. The report draws on a recent coverage by The Hindu reporting limited access to Bedaquiline, which has been touted to be the most promising drug for the treatment of multi-drug resistant tuberculosis (MDR-TB) and is patented by US based company, Janssen. Subsequently diverging from the Hindu report, Prashant and Balaji take us through their own research on the

SpicyIP Weekly Review (March 4 – 10) Read More »

Finally, The Hindu Acknowledges the Clinical Trials Issues Regarding New TB Drugs but through Rose-tinted Glasses

The Hindu published yet another story in today’s edition on the issue of access to the new TB drugs like bedaquiline and delaminid. We’ve been tracking The Hindu’s coverage of this issue on the blog over here, here and here. Unlike the earlier reportage, The Hindu has finally acknowledged some of the issues that we have flagged relating to safety and efficacy of both drugs, given pending clinical trials. Today’s report notes that both drugs “are yet to pass large-scale

Finally, The Hindu Acknowledges the Clinical Trials Issues Regarding New TB Drugs but through Rose-tinted Glasses Read More »

How Does Inclusion of Patented Drugs in a WHO EoI Make Them More Affordable?

Over the last week, The Hindu has been reporting on the issue of access to two new TB drugs called bedaquiline and delaminid. As Balaji and I have pointed out in our last two posts on SpicyIP, there are serious issues with both stories that The Hindu published on March 3, 2018 and March 4, 2018. A third story published in today’s edition of the paper, titled “WHO launches plan for cheaper TB drugs” is with regard to a recent

How Does Inclusion of Patented Drugs in a WHO EoI Make Them More Affordable? Read More »

SpicyIP Events: 5th WTI – CWS Joint Academy on International Trade Law and Policy [June 4-29, New Delhi]

We are pleased to announce that The World Trade Institute of the University of Bern, Switzerland and the Centre for WTO Studies, Indian Institute of Foreign Trade, India will be conducting the 5th WTI – CWS Joint Academy on International Trade Law and Policy (“Joint Academy”), from June 4 to June 29, 2018 in New Delhi. The last date for submission of applications is March 30, 2018. For further details, please read the Call for Applications below: 5th WTI – CWS JOINT ACADEMY ON INTERNATIONAL

SpicyIP Events: 5th WTI – CWS Joint Academy on International Trade Law and Policy [June 4-29, New Delhi] Read More »

In a Well-Reasoned Judgment, Delhi High Court Rules in Plaintiff’s Favour in a Suit for Patent Infringement

In a well-reasoned judgment issued recently, the Delhi High Court (“Court”) adjudicated upon a suit for patent infringement comprising three patents over insecticides and herbicides. The three patents owned by the plaintiff relate to a herbicidal composition. The distinctive attribute of the composition developed by the plaintiff is this: it is an amalgam of 2 compounds each of which combats different kinds of weeds. More specifically, the composition consists of a compound called Metsulfuron, which controls grassy weeds and a

In a Well-Reasoned Judgment, Delhi High Court Rules in Plaintiff’s Favour in a Suit for Patent Infringement Read More »

RTI Replies Reveal the Deal between Janssen and the Ministry of Health on Bedaquiline

Co-authored with Balaji Subramanian, 5th Year student NALSAR University of Law Subsequent to our previous post, we got a copy of some of the correspondence between Janssen and the Ministry of Health under the RTI Act. We were under the impression that our request for the information was transferred to the CDSCO which then disposed the application without giving us the requisite information. However, it appears that the application was transferred back to the Central TB Division, which processed the

RTI Replies Reveal the Deal between Janssen and the Ministry of Health on Bedaquiline Read More »

Patent Office Calls for Comments on Patent Working Disclosure and Form 27

(This post has been co-authored with Prof. Shamnad Basheer) [Edit: The deadline for submission of comments has been extended to March 23, 2018] As reported last month, in our Patent Working PIL, the Delhi High Court asked the Government to submit an affidavit outlining the proposed framework and timeline for enforcing the patent working disclosure mandate. The court also asked the office to consider reviewing/revising the Form 27 format to make it more optimal. To this end, the Patent Office

Patent Office Calls for Comments on Patent Working Disclosure and Form 27 Read More »

Special Report: The Smoke & Mirrors Surrounding the Approval of Bedaquiline

Co-authored with Balaji Subramanian, 5th year student, NALSAR University of Law Prologue Last Sunday, The Hindu ran a piece on its front page alleging that  the government was not even considering the option of issuing compulsory licenses for a newly patented drug called bedaquiline, despite access to the drug being restricted to less than 1,000 patients. Bedaquiline, which is currently the most promising drug candidate to treat multi-drug resistant tuberculosis (MDR-TB) was developed and patented by Janssen and The Hindu

Special Report: The Smoke & Mirrors Surrounding the Approval of Bedaquiline Read More »

SpicyIP Ranked 3rd in List of Top Patent Blogs in the World

We are extremely delighted to inform our readers that SpicyIP has been ranked 3rd in a list of top patent blogs of 2018 published by James Yang of OC Patent Lawyer on IPWatchdog earlier last month. This list is an update of the 2011 and 2009 lists where SpicyIP was ranked 5th and 4th respectively. The entire list of top 16 patent blogs of 2018 is as follows: IPWatchdog Patently-O SpicyIP IPKat Phosita OCPatentLawyer IP News Flash Patent Arcade Patent Baristas IP Spotlight Patent Dogs

SpicyIP Ranked 3rd in List of Top Patent Blogs in the World Read More »

Scroll to Top